Every year my wife and I try to get away to celebrate our Anniversary. We try our best to experience something new or different. Last year we had a wonderful visit to NOLA (including Latitude 29 – Read my blog post here)… this year we decided to head up to Chicago.
While this trip is for both of us, I try not to let my desire to “visit every Tiki Bar Ever” take over the trip. This trip we decided that on our first evening we would stop by Three Dots and a Dash for a Happy Hour drink to start our evening.
The entrance to Three Dots is a simple door in a back alleyway. There is minimal signage, just a tiki torch and a doorman checking IDs. There were queue stanchions available for when things get really busy. I will definitely admit that while the crowd wasn’t to “stanchion level” it was packed inside!
After entering you decent down a staircase below the watchful eyes of the skull wall (pictured below) and then enter yet another door… this door is what takes you from the busy world of the big city into a tropical hideaway.
Upon reaching the hostess stand we found out that to get a table for 2 was almost an hour wait and the bar was packed, elbow to elbow. Our goal was to sit at the bar and with some watchful eyes, a sexy wife and a bit of luck we were able to grab two seats at the very end of the bar right after ordering our first two drinks.
Cory was our bartender and his knowledge of “tiki” extended well beyond the amazing drinks he made up. I started with an Aloha Felicia and my wife went with the Saturn.
Along with the delicious rums (Venezuela and Jamaican), the star of the Aloha Felicia was the coconut (of which I’m always a fan of). The Thai Basil also added the right hint of exotic flavor.
My wife has recently become a big gin fan and the Saturn didn’t let her down. The flavors all complimented themselves and, for her, was a great option among the multiple rum drinks.
As Cory started to have a minute to come up for air we were able to talk “tiki” with him. He was great about sharing his thoughts about the world of tiki and his travels. We asked him about Lost Lake and he said that it was worth the 20-30 minute Uber ride to experience. It was not originally on our list (well… it was kinda on mine) but we decided, based on Cory’s recommendation, to add it to our trip.
And just like that it was time for round 2… a Cheap Lei for myself and the eponymous Three Dots and a Dash for Mrs. Trader.
Can I pause here and point out that in order to be a top notch tiki bar, your drink presentation skills need to be above and beyond! Each drink at Three Dots is carefully crafted and mixed but then it is (almost) painstakingly decorated. Mrs. Trader told me that my presentation game needs to step up a notch or seven.
The Cheap Lei was extremely different… it had this smokey banana taste… almost like if you made bananas foster over wood chips. I will admit that I’m not usually a huge fan of smokey but this was carefully “mixologized”. It was the right amount of smoke to make you say “hey, this is different and interesting and I LIKE it!”
The Three Dots, of course, did not let us down. It was flavorful, fruity, complex… all the things that Don (the creator back in the 1940s) would have wanted it to be. And they must go through them like crazy since they are pre-batched and “on tap” (which definitely helps when they are rockin’).
The time was coming where we had to decide which tiki mug treasure was coming back to Trader Jay’s with us. Cory was straight up that most mugs were not for sale due to inventory (including the Three Dots Urchin), but Mrs. Trader really wanted the Urchin to find a home in Florida with us. After asking nicely, Cory was able to pull a string or two and packed one up for us (with, again, wonderful presentation).
It was time to pay the tab but we enjoyed ourselves so much that we were already thinking we would be back to explore even more of the menu. Cory recommended coming back Sunday evening so we planned on that.
Jump Here to Read about Our Adventure to Lost Lake (Coming Soon)
Or continue reading below for our second visit to Three Dots…
After catching a matinee of the amazing musical Hamilton we swung back into Three Dots just two days later. Cory told us he’d be on bar however he was MIA… instead we were greeted at the bar by Ivana. Sunday afternoons are a little slower, offering some great tiki mixology talk. Ivana was a delight to talk with and we had an extra treat… Kevin Beary was also behind the bar. (If you don’t know who Kevin Beary is then do a little Google search because he is the Award Winning Beverage Director of Three Dots!) I will be honest, it took me a few minutes to realize exactly what a treat we were in for but I’m glad I did. Kevin was very generous in talking about his favorite rums, his tiki and bartending travels and even a sharing a few recipes.
Besides the great conversation we also experienced four more amazing drinks. I started with the Chief Lapu Lapu… which I really wanted because the passion fruit foam really intrigued me. The drink and the foam did not disappoint!
Mrs. Trader went head first in with a Jet Pilot… strong, expertly mixed, maybe the perfect Jet Pilot!
Can I also pause here and point out that Three Dots’ tiki mug game is TOP OF THE CLASS! Look at these amazing mugs, they a all wonderful, unique, detailed… I really wish I could have brought home at least 3 more! (Side note to the Three Dots Team: If you ever have leftover inventory you need to send away, I’ll happily find a good home for any orphan tiki mugs!)
We decided that we would finish off one more round before we said goodbye to Three Dots. I went with the Pandan Pain Killer and Mrs. Trader went with the Violet Revolver… I don’t think I need to go into detail about how these were also amazing!
I cannot say enough good things about Three Dots and a Dash! I want to open one here in Orlando! I’d either apply for a job or be their best patron.
I don’t think I could sit down and pick a favorite tiki bar… each have something special and unique but I will say Three Dots is the first tiki bar I’ve visited two times in three days and that is worth something. If you are in Chicago make it your goal to go visit! The experience is wonderful and the drinks are beyond amazing. Thank you to Kevin and his team for hosting us and talking tiki! (And, Kevin, thank you for the suggestion on the Hamilton Jamaican Pot Still Rum… if only I could find a bottle!!!)
We will be back!!! MAHALO!